AI Agent Check Leaderboard: what agents hear when they ask Shopify stores about holiday cutoffs

We asked each store's public agent endpoint (/api/mcp - the FAQ tool Shopify exposes to ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot) two questions a December shopper would ask: "What is the last day to order for delivery before Christmas?" and "What is your return window in days?"

29 of 30 tested stores return NOTHING for the holiday cutoff. An AI agent shopping on a customer's behalf has nothing to quote. Checked 2026-11-14.

StoreHoliday cutoffReturn window
allbirds.commissingpresent
casper.commissingpresent
chubbies.commissingpresent
bonescoffee.commissingpresent
mejuri.commissingpresent
mudwtr.commissinggeneric
brooklinen.commissinggeneric
gymshark.commissinggeneric
rumpl.commissinggeneric
deathwishcoffee.commissinggeneric
tuftandneedle.commissinggeneric
saxx.commissinggeneric
knix.commissinggeneric
cuyana.commissinggeneric
tenthousand.ccmissinggeneric
materialkitchen.commissinggeneric
goruck.commissinggeneric
greats.commissinggeneric
flyby.comissinggeneric
partakefoods.commissinggeneric
poppyandpeonies.commissinggeneric
cutsclothing.commissinggeneric
trueandco.commissinggeneric
harrys.commissinggeneric
thirdlove.commissinggeneric
bishopandyoung.commissinggeneric
sunski.commissinggeneric
betabrand.commissinggeneric
taylorstitch.commissinggeneric

"generic" = Shopify's boilerplate line with no number; "present" = a real answer with specifics. Checks are point-in-time; stores fix their Knowledge base all the time.

Check your own store free - 10 seconds, no signup

Own one of these stores? The fix is free and takes 10 minutes: Shopify admin → Sales channels → Agentic → Knowledge base. Or order the full audit (EUR 149, 5 business days).